้ปๅฌๅชๅญ | ใฝใณใทใซ #pixiv https://www.pixiv.net/artworks/103103751
็งใฎๅบ่บซๆ กใฏๅฎ่ณชๅ ฌ้ๆ ๅ ฑใชใฎใงๆธใใฎใงใใใๅบ่บซๆ กใฎไฝ่ฒ้คจใฎๅ ฅใๅฃใซใไบบ้กๆใฎๅญใใใจใใใๆ่กใธใฎๆใใพใๅญใใใใจใใๆจ่ชใๆฒใใใใฆใใฆใ็งใฏไปใงใใใฎๆจ่ชใ็ตๆงๆฐใซๅ ฅใฃใฆใใพใใ
Years from now, someone is going to cry about "Automaticc or Flickr used 'embrace and extend' to bully us! This always happens! They did this to us!"
But the reality is going to be that "At a time when millions of users were desperate for something, anything, other than Twitter... Automaticc and Flickr took the guesswork out of signing up for an Activity Pub based service that would protect you from Nazis. Noone else did."
The analogy that several Black users have said, is "Mastodon is the digital equivalent of fleeing 'regular' racism in the deep South, just to experience 'racism doesn't happen here!' racism in Boston." ๐๐
Mastodon has more cultural norms around not talking about racist abuse, than around preventing it from happening. I don't know how to convince y'all that this is bad.
So yeah, this creates an opening for centralizers.
@evan @markallerton @ks It's ironic and sad that we're seeing the biggest spikes in fediverse adoption in history precisely because users are fleeing a centralized network that is becoming less safe... and yet we still don't acknowledge that for social networks, safety is the P0 feature.
Yes, the fediverse is safer for some users than centralized social networks, and I'm truly happy for them. But for other users, it is much less safe.
There's increasing evidence that good moderation just doesn't scale well. Having a mod to user ratio of under 1 to 1000 seems ideal. There's all the opportunity for decentralized social to be safer than centralized. And we're squandering it.
By funneling marginalized users to big instances like mastodon.cloud and mastodon.social, letting them experience horrible abuse, and then blocking them for not using CW when they ask for help.
Personally I care a lot more about user safety than decentralization. I care about decentralization as it pertains to user safety, product innovation, and inclusion. Which is why for the day job, I choose jobs where I can make sure that small companies compete and win against the big company I'm at. This creates a healthier world, and works better for everyone.
But I don't value decentralization for decentralization's sake.
The best thing to do to "counter" this coming centralization is super easy to do, but from my short time observing here, it won't happen:
1. There should be stricter criteria for an instance being listed on "join Mastodon." Insufficient moderation gets you de-listed. Handle cynical false reports.
2. It should be easier for a new admin to just check a box and opt-in to a whitelisted federation that excludes the worst instances.
It's entirely possible for decentralized instances to provide safety, but most don't/won't. I'm super happy with hachyderm.io for example. โฅ๏ธ๐๐ฟ
But a larger company is going to integrate with the fediverse, and fulfill the most basic user feature request: "As a user of your product, I would like to know that signing up will not expose me to death threats from nazis" ๐คท๐ฟโโ๏ธ
Then more new users are going to flow there.
As a Black person, simply signing up for a Mastodon account can expose you to vile racist slurs and threats of violence. Most Mastodon users are one popular toot away from discovering that their instance mods are either unwilling or completely unprepared to deal with this.
Because a centralized whitelist was abused in a cynical attack years ago, the fediverse kinda gave up on that idea, and has been very resistant to it ever since.
I do agree that centralization is coming to the fediverse, but not for any of the reasons that most people on here think. That centralization is coming for the exact same reasons that centralization came to email, and it's a reason that many folks that would like things to stay decentralised keep ignoring.
And that is user safety.
A lot of Mastodon fans keep pretending that Mastodon is inclusive. It's not. But it could be.
ใใณใใฃใณใขใใผใใฎใใฑใขใณๆชใฟใคใใ ใใใ ใใใใณใใฃใณใฏๆชใ็ใ็ฉใ ใจใใใฒใผใใชใฎๅผทใๆๅฟใๆใใ
ใขใใฌใผใทใงใณใจใขใซใฆใณใๅๆญขใใใใซๅฏพใใๆๅผใฎๆฉไผใ้ฃใใ
ใชใใฉใซๆดปๅๅฎถใ้ๅ ฑใใใคใใณใใชใใฆใใฃใฆใใฎใโฆโฆใใพใพใงTwitterใฏ็ก่ฆใใฆใใใใ ใใฉใใใฆไปๅนดใฏใฉใใชใใใ
ๆค็ดขใปใณในใฃใฆใๅฎ้ใใฎๅ้ใฎ็ฅ่ญใจใฎใใ็ฎใ ใใชใใๆค็ดขใปใณในใ้ซใใฆใๆช็ฅใฎๅ้ใ ใจใใใใใฏใผใใ็ดกใใชใใๆค็ดขใงใใใฎใฏ่ชๅใซใใ็จๅบฆ็ฅ่ญใใใๅ้ใ ใใ
ใใใๆค็ดขใใงใใๆไปฃใงใใๅบ็ค็ฅ่ญใ่ชๅใง่บซใซใคใใฆใใใใจใๅคงไบใชใใ ใ
ใใใใไปฅๅใๆขใใฆใ่ฆใคใใใชใใชใผใใจๆใฃใฆๅบๆฐใปใณใฟใผใฎไบบใซ่ใใใใใฃใใใใฐใฐใฃใใ ใใงใใใฉโฆใใจ่จใใใฆ็ฎ็ใฎๆ ๅ ฑใๆธกใใใใใจใใใใ
#fedibird #fedibird_info #fedimovie
Q. ใๆฟๆฒปใใจใ่ถฃๅณใใฎใตใผใใใใใใจใใๅใฏๆฌๅฝใงใใ๏ผ
A. fedibird.comใซใคใใฆใฏใ็พๅจใใใใใใใใใใใ้็จใฏ่กใใพใใใ
ใใใฏๅไบบใๆดปๅใใSNSใฎไธญใงใไธ็ชๅค็ฎ็ใซไฝฟใใๅ ดๆใงใใใใใซใๅถ้ไบ้ ใๆๅฐ้ใซใชใใใใซ้็จใใฆใใใพใใ
ๅไบบใซๆ นใใ้ใใๆฟๆฒปใ่ถฃๅณใใใไปฅๅคใฎๆงใ ใชๆดปๅใไธไฝใจใชใใใฎใงใใใใใใใใใฉใใใฏๅๅใฎๅคๆญใงใใ
ใๆฟๆฒปใใจใ่ถฃๅณใใฎไปถใฏใFediMovie๏ผๅ็ปๅ ฑๆใตใผใใน๏ผใฎ่ฉฑใงใใใใจๆใใพใใ
ใใกใใฏMastodonใจใฏ็ฐใชใPeerTubeใจใใใทในใใ ใซใใๅ็ปใๅ ฑๆใใใตใผใในใงใใญใผใซใซใฟใคใ ใฉใคใณใๅปๆญขใใfedibird.comใจใฏ็ฐใชใใไธ็ทใซไฝฟใฃใฆใใไบบใฎๅฝฑ้ฟใๅผทใใงใพใใ
ๅคงๆๅธฏใง้ๅถใใใซใฏๅใใใๅฉ็จๅพๅใฎ่ฟใๅฐไบบๆฐใงใใใผใใ้ๅฎใใฆ้็จใใๆนใใใพใใใใพใใ
YouTubeใฎใใใซไธใถๆใซ้ใพใใใๅ่ชใงๅๆฃใใฆไฝฟใใใญใใจใใ่ถฃๆจใฎใทในใใ ใงใใ
ๆๆขใใงๅงใใใใฎใงใใฎใงใ้ๅงๅฝๅใฏใใผใใๅ ฑๆใใฆใใๅฐไบบๆฐใงใใใใๅพใ ใซๅฉ็จๅพๅใๅบใใฃใฆใใใใใ
ใใไธใคใใซใผใซใฎ็ฐใชใๆฐใใใตใผใใไฝใฃใๆฌก็ฌฌใงใใ
ไปใ่ชๅใๅฎๅฃฒใใใฆใใ่ช่ฆใฏใใใใใฉใๆขใซๅฎๅฃฒใใใฆใใใใใใซ้ซๅคใงๅฃฒใใใใใใใชใใใจใซๅฏพใใๆฏใใใใ
่ทใฎใใใใใ่ฆใฆใฏใๅๅ ฅใไปใฎ3ๅใฃใฆใใจใฏไปใฎ3ๅไปฅไธๅใใฃใฆใใจ๏ผๆญปใใงใใพใโฆโฆใซใชใฃใฆใใ